Cottage Pie: Right Back To My Childhood

A Cottage Pie is a wonderful homely British recipe of braised ground beef and root vegetables in a gravy topped with a crispy potato top.

A Cottage Pie is a wonderful homely British recipe of braised ground beef and root vegetables in a gravy topped with a crispy potato top.

Cottage Pie: Right Back To My Childhood!

Cottage pie is one of the most enduring food memories from my childhood. Not just from home but at my grandparents house, school dinners, friend houses.

No matter where I went you could guarantee that cottage pie was never too far from the ‘menu’.

It is essentially a really simple dish of ground beef, vegetables in a gravy all topped with mashed potato. Then baked in the oven to crisp up the mash.

You can play with it as much as you like but it should always remain a good old fashioned winter warming dish.

References to cottage pie date back to the 18th Century but they have always been rustic dishes. Traditionally they were a way to use up leftover roasted meat, but have become a frugal recipe using ground beef.

It joins a long list of British pies here on Krumpli, everything from a traditional pork pie to the great beef and ale pie get a look in. Of course, we also have lemon meringue pie too!

A Cottage Pie is a wonderful homely British recipe of braised ground beef and root vegetables in a gravy topped with a crispy potato top.

The Perfect Mashed Potato Topping.

The perfect mashed potato topping for a cottage pie recipe should be just that, mashed potato. It is important that the topping has some structure and should not be ‘pureed’ potatoes.

As a result, I avoid both cream and milk and stick with a butter content of around 10%.

This is slightly different to the mashed potato that I use as a side dish, which uses both butter and cream to the tune of 25%. That is seriously indulgent, you should check out that in my faggots and mash recipe!

I’m very much an advocate of using a potato ricer for mashing potatoes you eliminate all lumps. As for cooking, either boil or bake your potatoes I switch freely between the two.

I promise you I am not being all pretentious by piping on my mashed potato.

I am certainly not a dab hand with a piping bag as you can probably tell, but I love a nice crispy topping on my cottage pie.

The crispy parts of the mashed potato all occur at the ‘sharp’ edges of the mashed potato. By piping on the mash with a star-shaped nozzle you increase both the surface area of the mash and the sharp edges.

Mor surface area and more sharp areas mean more crispy bits. More crispy bits equals better cottage pie!

However feel free to just spread over the mash and then use a fork to break up the surface. You will get some nice crispy bits just not enough for my liking!

I have seen many people add cheese to the mashed potato. As far as I am concerned it is a travesty, cheese and gravy should never be mixed! But if it is your thing then knock yourself out you crazy person…

A Cottage Pie is a wonderful homely British recipe of braised ground beef and root vegetables in a gravy topped with a crispy potato top.

What Is The Difference Between Shepherds Pie and Cottage Pie?

A cottage pie should not be confused with a shepherds pie. They are in many ways the same recipe, but a shepherds pie is made with lamb rather than beef.

I do have a little confession to make… I am far from being an authenticity ‘Nazi’ when it comes to recipes but a little part of me dies inside when I see cottage pie recipes “incorrectly” called shepherds pie.

It is quite laughable and a little bit daft, I am sure we all have little things that irrationally get under our skin, this one is mine.

Particularly given the fact that the contents of cottage pie, which predates shepherds pie, were never originally fixed.

However, by the time the 20th century got into full flow, there was a distinct difference.

It’s OK, I don’t turn into a raving psycho or one of them crazy keyboard warriors. I tut and then roll my eyes and mutter to myself before moving on.

A Cottage Pie is a wonderful homely British recipe of braised ground beef and root vegetables in a gravy topped with a crispy potato top.
Cottage Pie

Cottage Pie

Yield: 4 Servings
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 1 hour 15 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour 25 minutes
A Cottage Pie is a wonderful homely British recipe of braised ground beef and root vegetables in a gravy topped with a crispy potato top.

Ingredients

  • 1 kg Potatoes, Peeled and chopped about the size of a golf ball
  • 100 g Butter
  • 75 g Onion, Medium Chopped
  • 2 Cloves Garlic, Thinly sliced
  • 500 g Ground Beef
  • 100 g Carrot, Roughly Chopped
  • 100 g Parsnip, Roughly Chopped
  • 1 Tsp Dried Thyme
  • 200 ml Red Wine
  • 150 ml Tomato Passata, Tomato Sauce in the US
  • 250 ml Beef Stock
  • 1 Tbsp Worcestershire Sauce:, Use Lea and Perrins, everything else is a poor imitation

Instructions

  1. Boil the potatoes until soft and mash adding in the butter, set aside until you are ready to build the pie, ensure you check for seasoning and add salt as required
  2. Cook the onion in a frying pan over a medium high heat for 5 minutes with a splash of oil
  3. Add in the garlic and cook for 1 minute
  4. Turn the heat up to high, add the beef and fry for 5 minutes
  5. Preheat your oven to 180°C
  6. Add in the carrot and parsnip, dried thyme and then pour in the red wine and allow to reduce until almost dry about 15 minutes
  7. Add in the tomato passata and beef stock and reduce by half
  8. Remove from the heat and then add in the Worcestershire sauce, check the seasoning and add salt and pepper to taste and layer into your serving bowl or bowls
  9. Pipe on your mashed potato (you can layer it on any other way you like)
  10. Place in the oven and bake for 30 minutes

Notes

You don't have to pipe the potatoes if you do not wish, I like to as it means I get lots of peaks on the mashed potato to go crispy.

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 4 Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving:Calories: 855 Total Fat: 43g Saturated Fat: 21g Trans Fat: 2g Unsaturated Fat: 17g Cholesterol: 165mg Sodium: 633mg Carbohydrates: 67g Fiber: 8g Sugar: 9g Protein: 43g

Readers Comments

16 thoughts on “Cottage Pie: Right Back To My Childhood”

  1. I often make shepherd’s and cottage pies- I do prefer the lamb somehow but never piped the potatoes so nicely – what a nice idea! – will definitely remember this – has a proper waw factor – kids will love it even more 😉

  2. Love the piping, much better than boring fork patterns and much more crispy! Definitely a family favourite as we couldn’t afford lamb anyway. In our house peas were added or baked beans but your recipe looks much classier!

    • Lamb was rare for us too, dspite being bought up in a family of butchers… Cottage pie was much more common than shepherds pie and I honestly thought that baked beans were a bizarre thing that few did, nice to hear that’s not the case.

  3. Did you mention food Nazi? Hello! I must say though that Italian food is lambasted all the time, pizzas that are not pizza, carbonara that are not carbonara. Not to talk about Alfredo sauce, which in Italy we have no idea of what it is. I am with you, don’t confuse the Sheppard pie with a Cottage pie. Luckily I have lived in England long enough and I have learned to refrain my dramatic emotion, so moving along. I love your idea of piping the mash to make it more crispy and since my husband likes it soft, I will cut all the tops and eat them.

    • It’s just food, I don’t get it… Authenticity is for museums as far as I am concerned, food is to be loved, shared and enjoyed, so I stick with my atypical tut and move on 😉

  4. You learn something new everyday right? Well consider me educated! Thanks for the great recipe and the foodie knowledge as well 🙂

  5. This is home-cooking comfort food at it’s best. My mother always called this Shepherd’s Pie. She never used carrots or parsnips, but corn instead. This recipe sounds so good! I’ve printed this one out to try myself.

    • Thanks Tina, the name thing seems to be a common theme… I think that Shepherds pie has become the generic name for a ‘mash’ topped pie like this… I am sure my Grandma is rolling in her grave 😉

  6. So you mean to tell me that every time I have made a “shepherd’s pie” with beef, I am really making a cottage pie? Good to know! And this looks delish.. .next time I make some I’ll have to try your crispy potatoes trick 🙂

    • Yup sorry… I am sure it is a British thing and that globally shepherds pie has become the name for a potato topped pie, but you can take the boy out of Britain but you can’t take Brit… 😉

  7. i think the piping’s brilliant! What size tip did you use? (I also have to confess to having the same attitude toward “shepherd’s” pie that don’t have lamb.)

    • Cheers Peter… It is a bit of a giggle and reminds me of one of my haircuts from the 80’s 😉 It is functional too though, the more surface area the more crispy bits there are and the crispy bits are my favourite!

Leave a comment